Hospital To Pay ₹ 21 Lakh For Medical Negligence

“washing its hands off” and trying to wriggle out of its “mischief”


New Delhi: A decade after his wife died due to medical complications, a man has won his battle with a city hospital for negligence. Slapping G M Modi Hospital with a Rs 21 lakh penalty, not only did Delhi State Consumer Redressal Commission find it guilty of medical negligence, but also said that “unnecessary” surgeries were carried out. Besides, the hospital had also included surgeries that were never done to inflate the medical bills.

While imposing the penalty, judicial member O P Gupta and member Anil Srivastava accused the hospital of “washing its hands off” and trying to wriggle out of its “mischief”. Delhi resident Vishnu Priya Giri had been admitted to the hospital on a complaint of stomach pain and she was operated upon on February 6, 2006 for “laparoscopic cholecystectomy mucocele gallbladder type-I” with multiple “fibroids uterus”.

The discharge summary, however, showed that the patient had undergone laparoscopic cholecystectomy and common bile duct (CBD) exploration with laparoscopic assisted vaginal hysterectomy. The complaint alleged that there was no evidence to show a block in CBD requiring the surgery. “Besides, no consent was obtained. The patient could not fully recover. Pain never subsided,” it added.

Subsequent tests at RML Hospital showed the presence of multiple cancerous tumours, which were in their advanced stage. Vishnu Priya eventually died on January 1, 2008. The patient’s husband, Madhusudhan Giri, alleged that the surgically removed gall bladder was not sent for histopathological examination and only the uterus was sent. He contended that the gall bladder got damaged during the operation and the bile in it spilled inside causing irreparable damage to the organs.

Dr Manoj Malik, medical superintendent and consultant at G M Modi Hospital, accused the operating doctor, Dr A K Panigrahi, for being responsible and denied any role. Even Medical Council of India (MCI) upheld the decision of Delhi Medical Council where “medical negligence on the part of Dr Panigrahi and complicity of the hospital” was found.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here